EssayForum.com
Free Academic Writing and Research Help
Faq / Register

All Threads / Unanswered      Welcome: Guest 38.107.191.94

» Username:   » Password:    [Forgot password?]

Only registered members may post here. Please login or REGISTER first.

Essay Forum / Undergraduate Admission Essays /

Crossroads - Columbia University Personal Essay


Mariam892 1-7 Edited by: Moderator  Oct 13, 09, 05:19pm  #
Hey guys! This is my Columbia University personal essay. I really really really need this to be perfect since my SATs are kind of lacking (combined 2000). Columbia has been my dream school for a while, so hopefully this essay can get me in! This idea has been in my head for a while and I've finally got it onto paper. Constructive criticism would be amazing! Thanks!

Prompt: Write an essay which conveys to the reader a sense of who you are. Possible topics may include, but are not limited to, experiences which have shaped your life, the circumstances of your upbringing, your most meaningful intellectual achievement, the way you see the world - the people in it, events great and small, everyday life - or any personal theme which appeals to your imagination. Please remember that we are concerned not only with the substance of your prose but with your writing style as well. We prefer that you limit yourself to approximately 250-500 words (or 1-2 pages).


Crossroads

The smell of kabob and other meats I couldn't quite place lingered in the air. A staccato of footsteps and a symphony of voices resonated in the house. To anyone else it would seem as if a loud fight was going on, however, to the trained listener, like myself, this was just an average conversation. Why must getting read for every family outing become such a great ordeal? I thought to myself. Equipped with enough food to feed an army, and cars full of old blankets and plates, we set off to Woodmere Park to celebrate the first day of summer.

SEE BELOW

Mariam Mahbob
 
EF_Stephen [Moderator] 0-280  Oct 13, 09, 05:45pm  #
This is very interesting. The writing is excellent. You went from a specific experience to a broader perspective, and led the reader through it flawlessly.

I can find no fault with it.

Stephen, EssayForum.com
 
Liebe [Contributor] 4-583  Oct 13, 09, 06:27pm  #
Mariam892:
The smell of kabob and other meats I couldn't quite place lingered in the air. A staccato of footsteps and a symphony of voices resonated in the house. To anyone else it would seem as if a loud fight was going on, however, to the trained listener, like myself, this was just an average conversation. Why must getting read for every family outing become such a great ordeal? I thought to myself. Equipped with enough food to feed an army, and cars full of old blankets and plates, we set off to Woodmere Park to celebrate the first day of summer.

^I am pretty sure that the agreed spelling is 'kebab'.
Also, getting 'read'for every family or getting 'bread'?
I think the 'trained listener' part has an element of haughtiness to it, however that is just my personal opinion.

Mariam892:
Either way, I was still dragged to these, in my opinion at the time, "boring family rituals"

^By mentioning 'opinion at the time', that sets me, as a reader, to know what the next few paragraphs are going to be about. Boring family, actually became part of a very meaningful experience. As you mentioned kebabs before, I can fairly assume that you are going to bring in cultures as well.
I would assume that you would want to try and engage your reader, because I, knowing what the story will be about, will lose reader interest.


Mariam892:
I escaped the car and breathed in deeply like a prisoner who was denied fresh air for years.

^Escaped ''from'' the car maybe?
I understand the simile, but I do not think it works out too well over here. It is creative however.

Mariam892:
ements like "This country is unfair to foreigners..." and "I try ten times harder than these people just to make the same..." I rolled my eyes at, "these people" and "this country," thought I did sympathize with my parents at some points.

^At some points? Your father is lecturing you at this point in the essay, however 'some points' is just too general in terms of time.

Mariam892:
During Ramadan, when people asked me why I didn't eat food, I would respond with a simple, "I'm not hungry," and proceeded to change the topic.

^That is not denying your Afghani culture. Ramadan is Islamic. Shifting topics does not necessarily mean that you were trying to be American. It can also just suggest that you did not want to have to go through the lengthy explanations of what Ramadan is etc.


Mariam892:
I dreaded the after Christmas ritual of sharing what presents we received. I failed to notice it at the time, but I had attained a dual identity, one that conformed, and the other that questioned.

^Well. Receiving presents on a Christmas has become a western culture. Christmas is to commerate the death of Jesus, or even in Islam, Isa. The concept of exchanging gifts is a new one, seeing as how the image of Santa Clause only came into existence a few centuries ago.
I do not really know what you are trying to say here. Earlier, you were denying your Islamic heritage. So over here, is it a problem with not being Christian, or is it a problem of not being American?

Mariam892:
It wasn't until high school that I started to accept my Afghan culture. Strolling through the halls, I could hear several languages besides English being spoken and often spotted flags from different countries attached to backpacks. The notion of shifting from conformance to individuality was startling at first. Eventually, upon meeting some of my now closest friends, I learned from them to be more open with myself. Now, during Ramadan, I can explain why I'm not eating, and during Christmas time I can feel comfortable not receiving presents.

^If this realization came about in high school, why did you mention the earlier scenes with your family etc. I do not see a relationship.
Also, this realization is a bit sudden. Considering that this moment has been impactful, I would suggest more detail.

Mariam892:
I am from two completely different cultures and belong to neither one. Sometimes in life we are forced to choose certain paths. With my cultures, however, I choose to remain at the crossroads.

^Remaining at the crossroads? That suggests that you will continue to be in denial and be unsure of your identity. That further suggests you are confused.

Faisal P, Essayforum.com Contributor
 
Mariam892 1-7  Oct 13, 09, 06:52pm  #
thanks for the advice, i'll keep that in mind.

but in terms of why i included the beginning, it was to describe what my family is like, i then go on to describe how i'm like in school.

Mariam Mahbob
 
Mariam892 1-7 Edited by: Mariam892  Oct 14, 09, 05:59pm  #
Oct 15, 09, 08:39pm - Attached on merging:
Puzzle Pieces - Columbia University Essay

Hey guys! This is the personal essay I'm writing for Columbia University! It's my dream school. Please edit, or tell me what you think! Thanks. :)


Prompt: Write an essay which conveys to the reader a sense of who you are. Possible topics may include, but are not limited to, experiences which have shaped your life, the circumstances of your upbringing, your most meaningful intellectual achievement, the way you see the world - the people in it, events great and small, everyday life - or any personal theme which appeals to your imagination. Please remember that we are concerned not only with the substance of your prose but with your writing style as well. We prefer that you limit yourself to approximately 250-500 words (or 1-2 pages).


Puzzle Pieces

The smell of kebab and other meats I couldn't quite place lingered in the air. A staccato of footsteps and a symphony of voices resonated in the house. To anyone else it would seem as if a loud fight was going on, however, to the trained listener, like myself, this was just an average conversation. Why must getting ready for every family outing become such a great ordeal? I thought to myself. Equipped with enough food to feed an army, and cars full of old blankets and plates, we set off to Woodmere Park to celebrate the first day of summer.

My family had a habit of turning every small, insignificant event, such as the first day of summer, into a huge episode. Whether it was because they actually considered these events of great importance, or whether they were looking for excuses to have family "get-togethers", I wasn't sure. Either way, I was still dragged to these, in my opinion at the time, "boring family rituals". I couldn't see the enjoyment in being stuffed into a car like a forgotten article of clothing into an already full suitcase, only to arrive at a park where I'd be mauled by mosquitoes and stories of "back home." Or worse, being forced to help my grandfather with the puzzles he consumed his time with.

After a grueling one hour drive, full of rambunctious laughter from the adults and loud Hindi music, we finally reached the park. I escaped from the car and breathed deeply like a prisoner denied fresh air. I proceeded out of the car by slamming the door. Just before sighing in relief, I realized my mistake as I heard my father shouting. "Do you have a brain? What if you broke the door? That costs money! You have no sense of value, do you?" I almost answered his questions with a snide response, but decided against it, thinking better of it. "You grew up in America, but that doesn't mean you have to act like one. Back in Afghanistan..." Here we go again, I thought. Everything always led back to a drawn-out, exaggerated anecdote from "back home." By the time he was done lecturing me he was more talking to himself and venting his own frustrations about America with statements like "This country is unfair to foreigners..." and "I try ten times harder than these people just to make the same..." I rolled my eyes at, "these people" and "this country," though I did sympathize with my parents and their situation. They were high society people living low class lifestyles who were trying to raise me to be the best Afghan daughter. Too bad, we're living in America.

Growing up, school was the only place I could escape the crazy lifestyle I had at home. I could be whoever I wanted to be, which at the time I thought, was my "true self." In middle school, I dissociated myself from my Afghan culture and tried to adopt a more "American" persona, as my parents would put it. During Ramadan, when people asked me why I didn't eat food, I would respond with a simple, "I'm not hungry," and proceeded to change the topic. I dreaded the after Christmas ritual of sharing what presents we received and often created stories to steer suspicion from who I was. I failed to notice it at the time, but I had attained a dual identity, one that conformed, and the other that questioned.

It wasn't until high school that I started to accept my Afghan culture. Strolling through the halls, I could hear several languages besides English being spoken and often spotted flags from different countries attached to backpacks. The notion of shifting from conformance to individuality was startling at first. Eventually, upon meeting some of my now closest friends, I learned from them to be more open with myself. Without realizing it, I had made more friends being different than being the same. Now, during Ramadan, I can explain why I'm not eating, and during Christmas time I can feel comfortable not receiving presents.

"Bia, bia, Mariam!" my Grandfather shouted. Shaking me from my reverie, I looked up from where I was reading under the shade of a tree and saw my grandfather looking at me expectantly with a smile plastered on his face. He was working on his latest puzzle, a picture of two doves sitting next to each other. Placing my book to the side, I walked up and sat myself beside my grandfather so we could finish the puzzle together.

People may be said to resemble, not the bricks of which a house is built, but the pieces of a picture puzzle; each differing in shape, but matching the rest, and thus bringing out the picture. I am from two completely different cultures and belong to neither one. My cultures, like the pieces of a picture puzzle, create the picture that is me.

Mariam Mahbob
 
EF_Kevin [Moderator] 2-3981  Oct 15, 09, 07:17pm  #
Wow, excellent ending. The whole thing is excellent.

This sentence: People do not resemble the bricks from which a house is built, but rather, the pieces of a picture puzzle -- each differing in shape, but harmonizing with the rest, and thus bringing out the picture.

Excellent job!! Based on their prompt, I think this essay is perfect. It really is good reading... I mean, it reads really well. You might consider incorporating some ideas about your college/career plans, but that is not necessary.

Kevin, EssayForum.com
 
EF_Stephen [Moderator] 0-280  Oct 15, 09, 08:45pm  #
I thought it was great the first time. This is even better. Don't do anything else to it.

Stephen, EssayForum.com
 
gongan 2-33  Oct 18, 09, 03:26pm  #
Awesome! The metaphor you used to end the story with is the icing on the cake.
The only minor change I would like to suggest it that in the section with:
"Eventually, upon meeting some of my now closest friends, I learned from them to be more open with myself."

I would change it to "In high school, I met and befriended many of my classmates, each distinct and unique. My now closest friends taught me to be more open with myself." Or something along those lines because "Eventually, upon meeting..." sounds somewhat awkward. But the essay is agree really unique and I'm just being picky because I hope you will get into Columbia! ;)

* I hope that you can also look over my essays "Homeless" and "Buchenwald"! Thanks!
 
Mariam892 1-7  Oct 18, 09, 07:52pm  #
thanks so much! yeahh, i changed around a few of the awkward sentences. AHH! i hope i get in to, hahaha. and of course, i will most certainly look over your essays. :)

Mariam Mahbob
 
gongan 2-33  Oct 20, 09, 12:49am  #
I heard that Columbia is actually the most expensive Ivy to go to, but you'll have nothing to worry about because with your pro writing skills, you'll easily win some scholarships or grants!;)
 
gongan 2-33  Oct 25, 09, 04:37am  #
Columbia's a great school! Are you also planning on applying to NYU? I'm not positive, but I think you need to indent at the start of new paragraphs if possible.

I just revised my essays. If you could look over them, it'll be greatly appreciated! Hopefully, it'll help you too!!
 

Essay Forum / Undergraduate Admission Essays /
All Threads / Unanswered / Random / Search     Go UPtop of page

Similar threads to: Crossroads - Columbia University Personal Essay

Previous thread Next thread
FSU essay [Latin ViRES] Non sibi sed partiae

This thread has been closed.
 
All times are CST [GMT -6]

__________________________________

Home - Search - About Us - Faq - EF Contributors - Contact Us

Copyright (C) 2006-2009 EssayForum.com  Disclaimer, Privacy Policy, TOS  EssayForum RSS