EssayForum.com
Free Academic Writing and Research Help
Faq / Register

All Threads / Unanswered      Welcome: Guest 38.107.191.90

» Username:   » Password:    [Forgot password?]

Only registered members may post here. Please login or REGISTER first.

Essay Forum / Undergraduate Admission Essays /

Common App Essay - Diversity as a novelty?


Haru0422KR 1-12 Edited by: Moderator  Oct 30, 09, 08:36pm  #
Thank you in advance for your time.. Any comment is appreciated!

Topic: Evaluate a significant experience, achievement, risk you have taken, or ethical dilemma you have faced and its impact on you.



As a counselor ...

SEE BELOW

Alright, here is my concern. My original topic was - and still is - diversity. I used to think diversity was a novely, living in Korea where you rarely see foreigners on day to day basis. But through my experience in Canada, and through interactions with Ms. Hurteau and many diferent people, I realized the positive aspects of diversity, and this meant a lot to me.
But I feel that this essay, even after being polished 100000000 times, is more concerned with my adapting to life in Canada in general and impact of Ms. Hurteau. What do you think??


Also, as you can see, this essay is focused on Cornell. After applying for Cornell's early decision, I will have to send this essay to other universities for regular decision. Any tips on how to end this essay without mentioning a name of university?



Once again, thank you for help.

Jay Chun
 
Awreccan 2-9  Oct 30, 09, 10:31pm  #
hmm i agree that it's too much of your experience and too little evaluation. i understand that the idea about diversity is kind of straightforward and doesn't require much explanation, but when compared to the size of the rest of your essay, it's really minuscule. you might wanna talk about what you've leaarnt abt diversity more. give concrete examples like how - i dunno - u've started learning words from other language or sth. yeah.

one thing i really liked is the obvious contrast between your english when you came to canada and what it is now - it's quite impeccable, and i hope you're proud of it haha! just some problems - i found the word protean quite problematic - maybe i'm under-read, but i've only ever read that word in relation to small things...try using a diff word. that's about it! good job!

Samdish Suri
 
Haru0422KR 1-12  Oct 31, 09, 12:38am  #
how about i change the topic to

A range of academic interests, personal perspectives, and life experiences adds much to the educational mix. Given your personal background, describe an experience that illustrates what you would bring to the diversity in a college community, or an encounter that demonstrated the importance of diversity to you.

???

Jay Chun
 
krazzikittie 3-14  Oct 31, 09, 01:42am  #
not a single black haired, scrawny looking folk


you saying koreans are scrawny, son!?!?

Anyway, i know exactly how you feel, and wrote my common app essay about a similar topic.good luck!

Mirea Kim
 
Haru0422KR 1-12  Nov 1, 09, 05:57pm  #
Bumppp

Jay Chun
 
meisj0n 3-31 Edited by: meisj0n  Nov 1, 09, 06:06pm  #
You're not supposed to bump threads. mods may delete the thread..

well, just by glancing at a few sentences, it's clear that a lot of it is descriptive. then again, people like show and not tell? not really sure how to help other than cut it shorter. make it clearer why your trip to Canada affected you and how. then again if you cut too much it's gonna take away from who you want to show yourself as. more evaluation and the impact.

but this is the common app essay right? unless you're only apply to cornell.

then again, if you want to focus on this topic:

A range of academic interests, personal perspectives, and life experiences adds much to the educational mix. Given your personal background, describe an experience that illustrates what you would bring to the diversity in a college community, or an encounter that demonstrated the importance of diversity to you.

then maybe you can focus more on how being from a different country and how your canada experience affected you

Jonathan Hsu
 
EF_Kevin [Moderator] 2-3974  Nov 1, 09, 09:50pm  #
Wow, I'm so impressed by the essay and feedback in this thread. But yes, you are not supposed to bump threads. In order to get help from people, go give ideas to other people whose essays are impressive, and ask them to give feedback.

I can't believe this essay is written by someone who was an ESL student! You write so well. My suggestion, though, is to make it so this is not all narrative. Sandwich the story in between a brilliant, thoughtful intro and conclusion paragraph. The intro and conclusion should tell the main ideas, the moral of the story. And the conclusion should refer back to a word or phrase from the intro. By doing that, you really impress the reader.

As for how to write the conclusion without mentioning the name of the school, I think that is the wrong approach. Write a few versions of the essay tailored to different schools. It does not have to take long. It is good to mention the name of the school.

Kevin, EssayForum.com
 
Haru0422KR 1-12  Nov 2, 09, 03:13am  #
Oh, sorry about bumping.
I did not know but really wanted some advice.

ANyways thanks for all the comments! I will try my best to revise it as soon as possible.

Jay Chun
 
lotm30923 1-44 Edited by: lotm30923  Nov 2, 09, 10:43pm  #
As a counselor led my parents and me to my new classroom at Minnekhada Middle School, It was clear that my parents were anxious. I tried reassur(ing) them, grasping my father's hand and whispering, "Everything is going to be just fine, dad, no worries." However, despite my brave demeanor I was just as nervous as my folks. It had been a matter of weeks since we had stepped off a plane from Korea and began to begin a new life in British Columbia. The airport and rush and hustle of people around me were familiar, yet everything else was different. There was not a single member of the black-haired, scrawny-looking folk I'd been accustomed to.Now, Everything was different. With this reality came a new language to learn and new customs to adopt. And then, there was the potentially troublesome But more troubling was the process of learning how to live as a stranger – as a minority - in a new place. As we approached the classroom I thought back to our arrival in Canada (You are already showing the reader this statement, no need to repeat it by telling). The airport, the rush and hustle of people around me, yet not a single member of the black-haired, scrawny
the airport, the rush and hustle of people coming and going – and not a single black haired, scrawny looking folk I had been accustomed to seeing.
I held tight to what my mother had told me when I was as a small boy, "Treat everyone with respect and kindness, because there is little room for conservative-minded people in this protean world." And so, I believed Canadians would show me the this same graciousness that I had seen my parents extended to foreigners back in Korea. It was an unreasonable assumption, but I believed in it . I had no other option. but my youthful naiveté at the time did not allow for alternatives.


My belief in the kindness of strangers was tested on my very first day My first day at Minnekhada put this naiveté to the test . Accustomed to the authoritarian educational style of teachers in Korea, I was both pleased and dismayed to find that my new teacher, Ms. Hurteau required that her students be actively involved in virtually every aspect of learning. There were vigorous discussions and group activities. She talked(engaged) us rather than lecturing. If I had spoken English, all of this would have been wonderful. However, as an ESL student, I could only watch and listen as the class session rolled by. I was missing out yet no one seemed to notice or care that I wanted desperately to join in, with my fresh idea that I drew upon from my unique experience. Where was the kindness and support my mother had taught me to believe in? I eventually found it but from an unlikely source. Ms. Hurteau.



A few days after I arrived at Minnekhada, A few days after, Ms. Hurteau asked to see me during lunch. I knew it was Knowing it to be rare for a teacher to spend a lunch hour with a student, I couldn't help but feel a bit special. As we sat together, Ms. Hurteau told me that she understood how difficult it was for me to participate in class activities. She acknowledged that my lack of English skills posed a real challenge not only for me, but for her as well. Nevertheless, she vowed to teach me and encouraged me to set aside my fear of speaking English in front of the class. As the hour ticked away, Ms. Hurteau talked about covered everything from ways to improve my English, to my secondary education for the upcoming year, and to common Canadian customs. By the time our conversation ended, I discovered the meaning behind having a true teacher.

In the following months, Ms. Hurteau and I (we) had lunch often. We spent much of our time talking about Canada's vast landscape and its varied, complex cultural heritage. Ms. Hurteau told me that the people of Canada were a tapestry. They were French and Inuit, African and English, and yes, Korean as well. When Ms. Hurteau asked my ESL teacher Mr. Finley to join our lunch meetings, the fresh perspective made our conversations even richer and livelier. After each of these lunches, I would run home boasting to my family about the new knowledge I had gained, but even more profound was the realization that my parents had been right; there are kind and decent people everywhere.


Ms. Hurteau continued to encourage me to speak up in class. Mr. Finley's after-school tutor helped to improve my grammar and little-by-little my English improved.
Little-by-little my English improved through Ms. Hurteau's encouraging spirit and Mr. Finley's after-school tutor. As time passed, I became acclimated to Canadian culture and began to take an active role in group assignments. Among the wide range of books I began to read, Owl in the Family (underline) was my first and quickly became a personal favorite. It was a gift from Ms. Hurteau, who had read it to me chapter by chapter during our lunches.

My friendship with Ms. Hurteau Our friendship sustained me during my difficult first months in Canada, but then came the day. Ms. Hurteau was resigning. Her husband had passed away, and she was taking her children to live with her parents in Ontario. I was heartbroken. I grieved for my teacher and in some ways I grieved for myself for I knew that Ms. Hurteau she had done everything in her power to prepare me for the years ahead.
{What was a pupil to do when his favorite mentor leaves?} You might want to elaborate here a bit more, discuss the difficulties here.}

I am grateful so much for what Ms. Hureteau did for me. She helped me to become a successful student (I completed my ESL program in less than a year), taught me how to find friendship among my classmates, and instilled within me much needed confidence at exactly the right time. But most of all, Ms. Hurteau taught me about how to celebrate diversity by setting the example. Her love of the multicultural panorama that is Canada imbued within me a similar admiration and a singular desire to continue living and working in such environments. This along with being immersed with those who hold the same values makes Cornell University the next logical step for me.


With its wide array of international programs,faculty, and student body representing the best tradition of North American multiculturalism, Cornell is to me what Canada was to Ms. Hurteau. I believe that the future success of our planet relies precisely on the kind of cross-cultural engagement that I discovered in Canada. Through its global outreach and service to the planet and people,Cornell expresses a true celebration for multicultural ideals, the same ideals first taught to me by my parents, and further enhanced by Ms. Hurteau.


Sorry, I was making more edits there. Overall I think your essay is fantastic. If you have noticed, I tried to put some suggestions that made it flow a bit better and forced the active voice. Your essay explains conflict well, but you could focus a bit more. And I will repeat what has already been posted, your English is outstanding. I'm Korean-American (born in the US) and was nowhere near this level when your age. Nice essay but like anything, you can always do more....I hope this helps and best of luck to you in your quest for Cornell. By the way, could you look over some of my writing as well? Thanks!

Jason J Rhee
 
Haru0422KR 1-12  Nov 2, 09, 10:51pm  #
Thank you so much!!!




That was EXTREMELY helpful!!!!!!!!! xD

Jay Chun
 
lotm30923 1-44 Edited by: lotm30923  Nov 2, 09, 11:28pm  #
You are very welcome. Good Luck!

Jason J Rhee
 
meisj0n 3-31  Nov 4, 09, 09:42pm  #
EF_Kevin

For the common app, once you submit to one school, most of the app closes for editing. so if you do use cornell, it will stay cornell for all your submissions.

Good luck with the essay. I was very impressed too.

*sry this post wasnt exactly pertaining to the thread.

Jonathan Hsu
 
EF_Kevin [Moderator] 2-3974  Nov 6, 09, 02:20pm  #
Jonathon, thanks!! That helps me a lot. If I were a student applying to college, I would want to find a way to tailor each essay to the school. Nobody likes to get something that is going to lots of different places, like a form letter.

Thanks for making me a little better at my job!!

Kevin, EssayForum.com
 

Essay Forum / Undergraduate Admission Essays /
All Threads / Unanswered / Random / Search     Go UPtop of page

Similar threads to: Common App Essay - Diversity as a novelty?

Previous thread Next thread
UIUC EC Prompt - Student Council Common App Essay-- A Train Ride In Japan

 
All times are CST [GMT -6]

__________________________________

Home - Search - About Us - Faq - EF Contributors - Contact Us

Copyright (C) 2006-2009 EssayForum.com  Disclaimer, Privacy Policy, TOS  EssayForum RSS