Good idea, Sean.
I also recommend taking the easy route, and writing 2 essays. Write two paragraphs about this theme in the first story, and then write a 2 paragraph essay about this theme in the second essay!
That would be the "opposing type" of compare contrast essay. The opposing type is when you describe the 1st thing in detail and then describe the 2nd thing in detail. (The alternative would be to use the "alternating type" of compare/contrast which involves a point by point comprison.) After writing about what each story said about life and death, write a paragraph that shows the similarities and differences among them.
Finally, at the end, look at the main theme that has emerged from YOUR writing, and go write an intro para, with thesis, to put at the beginning. After that, write a reflective conclusion paragraph, and you will be done!!
Kevin, EssayForum.com